Ellmers: 'I'm the one who should have died'

Ellmers: 'I'm the one who should have died'

Matthew Ellmers during an earlier court appearance. Judge Jack Billings denied requests by KVAL News and The Register-Guard to cover Tuesday's hearing with cameras.

Tools

By Laura Rillos KVAL News and Mark Furman KVAL.com


Heather Mulgrave


Connie and Jaziah Vermilyea


Nima Gibba

EUGENE, Ore. -- After pleading guilty to charges he drove drunk and killed 4 people in an accident he can't remember, Matthew Ellmers asked the judge to allow him to turn around and face his victim's family and friends.

"Never in my life would I have dreamed I would cause this much pain and suffering," Ellmers told them. "I know you're saying I'm the one who should have died. If not, that's what I'm thinking. I would trade places with any one of all of them.

"I thought a lot for the past five months about what I would say when this time came," he said. "I just hope you can understand I made a mistake, I made the biggest mistake of my life."

Ellmers changed his plea to guilty on all counts Tuesday morning. There was no plea deal with prosecutors

Ellmers -- in the hospital or in custody since the Jan. 21 crash -- faced almost 46 years in prison if ordered by the judge to serve the full sentence on each count one after another.

Instead, Judge Jack Billings chose to make Ellmers serve some of the sentences at the same time, effectively sentencing Ellmers to 20 years in prison.

"I've seen lots of defendants make statments to people," Billings said. "I've never seen anybody ask to face those he's harmed. That's never happened."

"Do you take full responsibility? Yes"

Ellmers entered the courtroom Tuesday morning dressed in the drab garb of the Lane County Jail, shackled at both the wrists and ankles.

Judge Billings and his staff had to return from vacation to conduct the change of plea hearing. Ellmers had earlier pleaded not guilty to charges of manslaughter, assault and DUI.

The court met Tuesday to hear his request to change his plea.

"Are you guilty or not guilty?" Billings asked.

"Guilty," Ellmers said.

Then he began crying and continued to cry as the judge asked him to verify the facts in the case against him.

Did it happen Jan. 21, 2009?

Yes.

Do you take full responsibility that you were behind the wheel?

Yes.

Were you intoxicated?

Yes.

Then the judge asked Ellmers about each victim in the crash, one by one.

Do you believe your driving caused the death of Nima Gibba?

Yes.

Do you believe your driving caused the death of Jaziah Vermilyea?

Yes.

Do you believe your driving caused the death of Connie Vermilyea?

Yes.

Do you believe your driving caused the death of Heather Mulgrave?

Yes.

Do you believe your driving caused serious physical injury to Jakobi Mulgrave?

Yes.

Did you drive with extreme indifference to human life?

Yes.

Icon
Current Temp 41.0 °F
Light Rain
More Weather

Upload directly from your mobile device.

Learn how

YouNews

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

On Demand

Resources and info you need to prepare for the switch to DTV.

Viewer Poll

What should Oprah do after her show ends Sept. 9, 2011?
Read more and join the discussion

  • Start a primetime talk show
  • Go into politics
  • Focus on the Web and her magazine
  • More philanthropic work in Africa
  • Whatever she wants; the world's her oyster!